Disney’s Frozen hits DVD this week. In the time between the
theatrical release and the DVD release, I’ve read countless Frozen reviews and
reflections. Because of some odd herd mentality,
I’ve decided to post my thoughts on Frozen as well. Besides, many of my
friends, relatives, and well-wishers still haven’t seen the movie yet, so this
is my last chance to “preview” it for them. Please be warned, this will be a
rather self-indulgent reflection, rather than an actual movie review.
Overall, I thought Frozen was a good movie. It mixed a new
kind of plot with classic Disney storytelling. It was a crowd pleaser, garnered well-deserved accolades for Disney animators, and completing some work on the international versions kept my
logo-designing cousin employed and out of trouble.
Producer Peter Del Vecho and my cousin, Brian Rishel, at the Studio's award party.
So, yeah, I liked Frozen, but I probably would have liked it
more if I had known what it was about it before I watched it. The articles I
read before actually seeing the movie had given me some false expectations.
I first became aware of Frozen’s existence early last fall when
I read a blurb from one of the animators. This animator was discussing the
challenges of working on an animation that featured “two female protagonists.”
Two female protagonists? What a promising description! Princess stories have
long been criticized for not including enough other female characters for the
princess to relate to. Two princesses would certainly help right that wrong.
Plus, while growing up, I was always very close with my own sisters, so this
was a kind of relationship that I wanted to to see explored.
Unfortunately, the blurb was misleading. Frozen is not a
story with “two female protagonists.” It is very much the story of Anna and her
quest to save her magical sister.
Here’s a mostly spoiler-free plot summary: Elsa and Anna are
the daughters of the royal family. Elsa was born with magic powers that let her
conjure ice and snow. As she grows, Elsa becomes afraid that her powers will hurt
someone, especially her beloved sister, Anna. So Elsa withdraws from everyone,
including Anna. Finally, when her powers become too much
to conceal, Elsa exiles herself. So Anna sets out on a quest to find her
sister, help her control her powers, and save the kingdom from eternal winter.
Along the way, Anna finds friends to help her and, somehow, acquires two
handsome suitors. So, yeah, while Elsa may be the one who puts the plot into
motion and gets the best song, the story clearly follows Anna’s journey.
There’s nothing wrong with making Anna the main character.
(In fact, I find it interesting that the girl without magic powers gets to be
the leading lady.) But I wanted to see more of Anna and Elsa working together.
That line “two female protagonists” had me holding out hope that they would
team up and cooperate sometime before the big finish. While familial love and sisterhood is the heart of the
story, we rarely get to see the two girls enjoying that relationship.
I sort of thought kids would get more out of Frozen if they
could see more of Anna and Elsa enjoying each other’s company. When I was a
kid, I loved animated Disney movies, but not all of them stayed with me. The
princess stories were the most quickly forgotten because they were the least
relatable. Relatable stories were the ones I wanted act out with my brother and
two sisters after the movie was over. If you suspect that my brother was
the one who put a stop to princess tales, you would be wrong. My sisters and I
gave up on princesses before he ever had a chance to veto them. Why? Because a princess
has too much power, and that makes the narrative impossible to share with other
girls. The girls who didn’t get to be the princess felt stuck waiting their
turn in the spotlight. Playing the princess was even worse because of the guilt
that came with putting oneself so far above the other sisters. So my family gravitated
towards the stories that were about teams instead.
As an adult, I could see that same scenario play out whenever
my little, princess-crazed cousins would try to reenact their favorite princess
tales. As soon as the idea to
play princess came up, it either turned into a battle over who gets to be Sleeping Beauty, or their was lot of awkward hemming and hawing as they
tried to figure out how to tell a fairytale with multiple princesses.
I wanted little girls to see Anna and Elsa getting along so
that they could incorporate the friendship into their own narratives, and,
perhaps into their own lives.
But, just because Frozen didn’t meet this expectation doesn’t
mean it failed. Instead of a story of cooperation, Frozen is a tale of
understanding. Everyone who’s ever had a sibling knows how Anna feels when
she’s waiting for Elsa to spend some time with her, as well as how Elsa feels
when she can’t give Anna that time and can’t quite explain why. Frozen is
not the story of how we feel when we’re together, it’s about how we feel when
we’re apart and what we’ll do to be together again.
-Marjorie Rishel
It's interesting, the idea of reenacting scenes from a movie with siblings. I remember doing that with my brother Jay, though you're right in that scenes between sisters are rare in the Disney animated canon. Ariel has six sisters, for example and she only has a few minutes of interaction with them onscreen in the film. In Brave you have the triplets, and again Merida only interacts with them properly in the animated shorts that promoted the film.
ReplyDelete